Why do parents spank their kids?
Should kids get spanked?
Here's how thirteen hundred comments to this question got broken up into three categories;
- Those who say absolutely not - we should not be spanking little kids.
- Some who say - sometimes.
- The rest say yes, of course, they need a good spanking.
The answer one gives is a 'tell'. It tells us where you're at in your life - and how you feel about yourself.
Parents who spank their kids are insecure and lack self control.
They're looking for the easy way out - a quick fix. Then the parent makes excuses for doing such a thing by claiming that there was no other way and that some kids require physical harm to teach them to behave. Which is utter bullshit. The real truth is, they are projecting onto their child their own unresolved wounds.

Let me ask you this - would you want your boss to hit you every time you did something that didn't align with their expectations? No? Why not? You're an adult, you can make sense of it, and process and overcome it can't you?
Yet, hurting someone smaller, younger and less developed than you is ok? Not to mention, your child - the one you brought into your family. Kids aren't like bird poop and just land on you - it all started with a decision and a choice.
Kids learn by example which is why you must lead by example. If you need to resort to hitting your kids how on earth do you expect your child to learn self control if what's being modeled is the lack of?
Here's what parents who spanking their kids say;
- By the 10th time of telling my kids to do something, I have had enough. By spanking, they have then learned that there are consequences to their actions worse than "please don't do that" or "that is not nice"
- There is a real difference between spanking a child and abusing a child
- Spare the rod spoil the child!
- There sure are some kids that require spanking for them to remember the rules.
- Go have kids and you'll answer yourself
- Because over the last twenty years kids have become very rude and disrespectful!!
- If you don't they ended up diluted like most people now days
- This is why we have a generation up to into their 30s now with this entitlement selfish mentality
- Some kids for some reason ask for it
- If mom or dad don't set them straight, someone in the street or in jail will
- Old school ways neva killed the kids
- Its not spanking.. it's teaching
- I was raised like that
- A little fear equalled ALOT of respect when I was growing up. Didn't hurt me one bit!
And the best one - or should I say worst?
The question should be why aren't enough parents spanking their kids today!
Of those in the 'yes' camp - many stated that's how they were raised. So even though times have changed and there is clear evidence (not that one should need it) that hitting small vulnerable children is detrimental, they continue the cycle. It's what they were taught, and what their grandparents were taught. It's all systematic and runs deep within family roots.
But when do you stop doing what's always been done and learn a better way? Violence is never better and hitting a helpless child who looks to you for safety and security is violent.
For the response that it teaches kids - it sure does. It teaches violence.
And fear equals respect is twisted. We respect people we admire not people who physically harm us.
It's the angry hateful parent who feels horrible inside who spank their kids...
...and wants to take it out on someone that can’t fight back.

Then there's boundaries. Parents who spank their kids don't seem to be able to set proper boundaries for their children without using physical force also signals something. Internal fear.
Generating pain through violence and shame instead of love and healing. You can't teach much good through such an approach. Spanking kids is a broken tool many parents use when they are desperate, and while desperation is understandable when you have kids...dishonouring their rights by hitting them is not.
Children learn to fear when they are hit. There is nothing respectful about it ("hence the comment a little fear equals ALOT of respect")
The damage caused from parents who spank their kids runs deep - even for those who want to say they were not affected by it.
Spanking is a pattern interrupt
Children living in fear of being yanked around, slapped, hit, cursed at, belittled do not grow into mentally healthy adults.
Can't you think of a better way to interrupt them?
And...perhaps you should put more empahsis on interrupting your own pattern of abuse instead of trying to control your kid.
Think about what you're really showing your child and the world.
- You have no self control
- There are unresolved issues from your own childhood
- You are in pain
- No coping strategies
- Out of control
- Brute force is how to get things done
- Control issues
- You're less developed than your child
- Outside circumstances rule your inner world
- Impatience
- Lack of self love
- Little or no self respect/or respect for others
Second best comment - Do they still spank? I thought we had evolved since the Dark Ages.
When you don't spank your kids, they will be kids who will be open to share their stuff that comes up. They will learn how to manage their own behaviour, and respect others and understand what it is to feel honoured in every human experience.
These kids grow up to have the best connections, with themselves and others. Not only will your children benefit.. but so will everyone they surround themselves with.
Kids need parents who teach Power.. Not Force.
Only then will we see a more evolved world.
If you're still on the fence about whetherparents who spank their kidsare doing it right - yes hitting your kids works. It works at allowing adults like you to think it’s ok to hit kids.
SuzieQ is an adoptive parenting coach and mother of three. As an adoptee herself, she wants what's best for the child, and as a parent, what's best for adoptive parents. Her mission is to help adoptive parents be their best selves so they can meet the needs of their child.
You can connect with Suzie to learn more about raising a happy, healthy adopted child. You can check out her podcast here.